How realistic should a world be? “Enough realistic.” (EK)
A quick scan of world builders shows, I think, on the one hand the highly detailed world builders who get great creative joy in sticking to scientific guidelines, and on the other, the creators who love to be totally free of the realism of our world with strong fantastical elements. I think most people fall somewhere in between, and there’s this tension between wanting to have some realism so you don’t break immersion, but you also want to follow your “what if” question that guides your building.
My answer to the question of “how realistic should a world be?” is “it depends on your goal.” I’ve taken a very leisurely approach to my world building in the sense that I’ve spent a reasonable amount of time experimenting with “enough earth realism” to build a continent that will, hopefully, let me explore how “nature” affects human cultures and societies (one of my world building Feynman questions).
In other words, I want to build a world, but I don’t want full control over it’s form. My earliest attempts of world building were very much working off cultural archetypes in our world without too much thought of geography, but they felt too much like their source inspiration – in which case I may as well just do some historical setting drama, but that’s not what I wanted either. I wanted the world to emerge, and for some surprises to work its way in which I haven’t anticipated. So my solution was to “build an apple pie from scratch”, as the legendary world builder World Building Pasta calls his blog.
This log isn’t a “how to” but a log of the scrappy process I took, and to see whether I’ll fulfil my goal in the long run. I fly by a lot of the detailed process of the steps, because there are already excellent videos that I followed by Artifexian and Madeline James. If anything, this log will be a curiosity for non-world builders, and maybe even an inspiration to other world builders that scrappy and cherry-picky scientific world building is fine depending on your goals.