Langue Verte

Using history to move forward the public dialogue on free speech and social justice.

State of the Debate || Should Free Speech Protect Racist Hate Speech?

As a Leftist in the United States, I am concerned about the power and influence of right-wing, racist, authoritarian groups and their ideas. Recent years have seen a spike in hate crime cases1, while recent news reports have indicated that the Klu Klux Klan and other racist, white nationalist groups have secured positions in state and local police departments.2 Far-right groups have taken over federal buildings, murdered protesters, and plotted to murder more.3 The march in Charlottesville, Virginia; the murder of parishioners at Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, South Carolina;4 and police violence against unarmed black men and women are all causes of immense concern. They demand serious legislation, changes in cultural attitudes, marches, peaceful protests, dialogue, community building, boycotts, and more. Black lives matter.

Read more...

Book Review 5 || The Censors and the Schools

While walking through the local rec center with a friend last Fall, I found this book on a free-to-take bookshelf. Written in 1963, The Censors and the Schools recounts the wave of right-wing censorship against school textbooks and classroom instruction in the late 1950s and early 1960s. It was nice to read this book, some of which covered ground I became familiar with when writing my master's thesis, some of which was completely new to me. The book presented me with some new research avenues I hope to explore in the future.

Read more...

State of the Debate: What's the Bigger Threat to Free Speech?

This week, anti-racist protesters in Portland, Oregon were picked up in unmarked vans, driven around, searched, and returned to the streets.1 For weeks following the death of George Floyd at the hands of the Minneapolis Police Department, reporters have documented hundreds of incidents, most of them by police, targeting them and their equipment. Peaceful protesters, some in high-profile cases, have for weeks been attacked by police using chemical irritants and other projectiles, resulting in serious injury. President Trump and federal law enforcement have made sweeping generalizations about protesters – calling them a “violent mob” and promising retribution by federal officials. Dozens of people protesting Breonna Taylor's death by police received felony charges for a peaceful protest – charges that have now been dropped.2 Democratic Governor Ralph Northam imposed a strict curfew on anti-racist protesters on Monument Avenue in Richmond, Virginia. Black Lives Matter protesters have had their chalk messages on public sidewalk erased by local officials.3 There is a pattern here of violence and intimidation being used against anti-racist protesters across the country by law enforcement and politicians. If that is not censorship, I am not sure what is.

Read more...

One Book Called Ulysses

Befitting an unusual book, the District Court opinion in the obscenity case against Ulysses is quite unusual, too.A Justice John M. Woolsey wrote the opinion, in which he declares that the book was not obscene. Therefore, it did not violate the Tariff Act of 1930 that banned the importation of obscene books. His opinion in December of 1933, was certainly unusual in that it was a rare high-profile overturning of an obscenity ban. However, it was also unusual in the novel argument that Woolsey made.

Read more...

Censoring of a Baby: Opposition to Birth of a Baby in print and film

On April 11, 1938 Life magazine published a series of thirty-five pictures entitled Birth of a Baby given to editor Roy Larsen by the American Committee on Maternal Welfare.1 Larsen and the Committee intended for the pictures, in conjunction with a film of the same title, to educate the American public about child birth. Their hope was to reduce the high rate of maternal mortality during childbirth. Despite this laudable purpose, for years both the film and the magazine article came under heavy censorship by religious and secular authorities. These authorities generally declared the film, the magazine article, or both to be obscene and therefore subject to the vast network of both informal and formal censorship that existed in the late 1930s.

Read more...

Free Speech Round-Up 10 | June 23, 2020

Today in free speech news, Virginia Governor Ralph Northam tries to shut down anti-racist protesters and an interesting op-ed in the Washington Post condemns police censorship.

Read more...

State of the Debate: Matt Taibbi on the Madness of Cancel Culture

Matt Taibbi is a journalist covering politics for the Rolling Stone, a podcaster, and a columnist with his own self-published website. On June 12, Taibbi put out an editorial on his site the crux of which is to criticize “cancel culture” on the political Left.1

Read more...

Free Speech News Round-up 9 | June 16, 2020

This week in free speech news we have Starbucks employees getting dress coded for supporting BLM, a pretty good op-ed in the Hill, violence against reporters during the recent protests, a case involving a controversial terrorist law in England, and the Trump administration continues to try and censor John Bolton's upcoming book.

Read more...

Book Review 4 || Susan Jacoby - Freethinkers: A History of American Secularism

In Freethinkers, Susan Jacoby argues strongly for a recognition of the long secular tradition in American politics and presents a call to action for freethinkers of all stripes to reclaim the public square dominated by right-wing religious fundamentalists.1

Read more...

Free Speech News Round-up 8 | June 10, 2020

In free speech news this week, the Trump administration continues to threaten the free speech of protesters, while some protesters are encouraging public universities in Southwest Virginia to reject students solely on the grounds that they have made racist social media posts. In other words, it is business as usual.

Read more...