How did I feel?
First, I felt worried.
I didn't attend orientation because my visa result came in late. So I didn't even know about the residence permit or that I had to do more paperwork. They didn't mind that I came to do the paperwork a bit later than the requirement, but I was sad for my recklessness. I just came in a new country. And I didn't even know how the deposit worked for my renting.
So seeing someone could be dead easily and quickly like that, it does not make me feel unsafe where I live now, but if I have a travel there or somewhere else, that is something I have to be more careful.
Worrying for myself quickly turned into empathy. Because I could see myself having a similar behavior at some point. Could be out of ignorance, could be out of defiance. I believe that people with kids would have more ways to place themselves in her situation and have more sympathy.
Now let’s analyze a different kind of people.
What if, when you have late paperwork, you blame the system for being unfair and ineffective?
What if, when you cause traffic trouble, you blame other people right away?
The result is that you keep the image of yourself as perfect. Yes, you never made a mistake. But you also can't put yourself in the situation when other people make mistakes or reckless decisions, and feel empathy for them because in your mind, it never happened to you.
So when a situation like this happens, everyone else feels sad and expresses empathy. Some of them will be performative. But some of them are genuine. There is pressure for you to be empathetic as well. After all, empathy is a highly appreciated trait in the culture.
Firstly, people expressing sadness reminds you that you don't have the same connection. That causes anger.
And secondly, you don't have any connection with this person to feel empathy. Because you are perfect.
If you choose to express pure anger, you are subject to being viewed as less desirable in society.
If you think you are empathetic, you try to convince yourself and orthers that you are empathetic, you do that by putting yourself in someone else’s shoes. At least that's the definition of empathy.
What are her shoes? You come up with a list that you can observe right away, she is a mother, she is a woman, she is a leftist (you think). Now you think, movies and societies say mothers want to take care of their children, so you tap in that direction. You also heard that leftists want revolutions, so you say, you understand her political cause as well, even though you dismiss her ideas as dumb. That makes you even more empathetic because you show that you can understand their emotional state even though you don't even agree with them.
Your empathy is what you borrow from movies, from songs, from culture. Not from your own experience. That's why it's always cringeworthy.



