Rockies Pitch

Rockies

DEC. 16, 2022, 10:12 A.M.

Rockies Pitch: A Colorado Rockies Baseball Newsletter


On Tuesday, Thomas Harding broke the news that the Rockies had signed right-handed pitcher Pierce Johnson. It soon emerged that the deal is $5 million for one year with $750,000 of incentives.

Bill Schmidt has been clear that the Rockies needed to add to their bullpen, especially with the loss of Carlos Estèvez and Tyler Kinley’s injury that will keep him out until mid-season. (In case you’ve forgotten — and no one would blame you if you did — the Rockies bullpen had MLB’s highest ERA last year, a miserable 4.82.)

That raises the question of what the 31-year-old righty brings to the Rockies as they continue to accumulate pitchers who learned to throw at elevation.

Start at the Beginning: Who Is This Guy?

Actually, it’s a pretty interesting story.

A native of Denver, Pierce Johnson attended Faith Christian Academy in Arvada. In 2009, he was drafted in the 15th round by the Tampa Bay Rays but instead opted to attend Missouri State. While with the Bears and majoring in business, Johnson was solid, finishing his junior year with an ERA of 4.76 over 75.2 innings.

In 2012, he was drafted in the first round (43rd overall) by Theo Epstein and the Chicago Cubs, signing for $1,196,000. (That’s a year before they drafted Kris Bryant.) He worked his way through the Cubs’ system and was added to their 40-man roster in 2015. In 2017, he was moved to the bullpen and in May made his MLB debut. It lasted one game (he gave up to unearned runs in an inning of work) before being sent back to the minors and ultimately being DFA’d.

Then, in September of 2017, the San Francisco Giants claimed him on waivers. He played with the Giants for two months before finding himself shuttling between the MLB team and the farm. In total, he threw 43.2 innings for the Giants.

In November 2018, he declared free agency and signed with the Hanshin Tigers of Nippon Professional Baseball in an attempt to re-set his career. While with the Tigers, he pitched 58.2 innings for an ERA of 1.38, including 91 strikeouts and 13 walks. (He was also a Central League All-Star.)

Here’s what Johnson says of his time with the Tigers:

“Everywhere I’ve been someone was like, ‘Let’s change this, let’s change that . . . I tried to be coachable and I think that was my downfall. I tried to please everyone when I should have focused on myself and what worked for me.”

He added: “I was filling up the zone more (in Japan). I was in better counts. I just did everything to help myself on the field instead of nibbling here and there and then I’m behind in the count and now guys know a fastball is coming. There, I was ahead a lot and that was my mentality.”

(There’s a pretty amazing story here about his wife needing to return to Colorado for a C-section at the time the Tigers were in the playoffs. Johnson found himself shuffling between the US and Japan while all this was going on. “It was a really hard month for us,” Johnson said. “The month of October was a blur.”)

In December of 2019, he signed a two-year contract with the San Diego Padres for $4 million. Actually, Johnson’s family had some history with the Padres. In the late 90s, his father, Don, had worked as the vice president of marketing for the Padres. Even though Pierce Johnson and his wife were Colorado residents, they had deep roots in Southern California.

And he was good. He struck out 104 in 78 2/3 innings with only 36 walks and an ERA of 3.09.

However, 2022 brought an interruption. Johnson suffered right elbow tendinitis that had him on the IL from April through September. During the season, he appeared in only 15 games — and he was not good, earning a 5.02 ERA, striking out 21 and walking eight. However, in three postseason games, he was for real: In 4 1/3 innings, Johnson struck out six, walked zero, allowed no runs, and watched opponents hit only .143 against him.

As a free agent, he went on the market, ultimately signing with the Rockies.

How Does the Stuff Look?

It’s good. He has a curveball (his favorite pitch — he throws it 64.1% of pitches) and 95 mph four-seam fastball (38.6% of pitches). He also has a sinker and a cutter, but he doesn’t use them much. Consider some specifics.

Twitter avatar for @qopbaseballMLB Quality of Pitch @qopbaseball

#Rockies Pierce Johnson 2022 Curveball Quality ⭐️ 4.71 QOPA (Top 27% MLB) ✅ Velocity (Top 6%) 🔥 Location (Top 13%) 🎯 Low Rise (Top 21%) Horizontal Break (Top 44%) @hardingatmlb

Image

Image

8:38 PM ∙ Dec 13, 2022

In fact, here he is in action.

Twitter avatar for @ReneeDechertRenee Dechert @reneedechert@masto.ai @ReneeDechert

Pierce Johnson

mlb.comPierce Johnson’s two strikeouts | 10/11/2022Pierce Johnson hurled two scoreless innings in relief for the Padres and collected two strikeouts while allowing no hits4:35 PM ∙ Dec 13, 2022

The question is whether it will play at elevation.

Here’s what’s interesting: He’s been effective at Coors Field, appearing in 11 games and facing 44 batters. He gave up six hits, and the batting average when facing him was .158. — and he never gave up a run.

How Will the Rockies Use Him, and Is the Bullpen Better?

Probably, he’ll be looking to earn the set-up job for closer Daniel Bard, but you probably already knew that.

And, yes, the bullpen is looking better: Jake Bird, Lucas Gilbreath, Dinelson Lamet, Justin Lawrence, Brent Suter, and Daniel Bard.

Clearly, they need more, but the Rockies are accumulating an experienced group of relievers, with three members of their pitching staff from Colorado.

It’s a good move though I think the Rockies aren’t done yet.


Accolades

Daniel Bard has joined Team USA.

Read more here. The WBC is going to be fun.


Old Friends


What I’m Reading

★ ★ ★

Sorry this week’s newsletter is short — the end of the semester has just been brutal. I’m looking forward to the break.

Thanks for reading —

Renee

@ReneeDechert (Mastodon) ★ @Renee.Dechert (Instagram) ★ @ReneeDechert (Post)


Trevor Story’s absence doesn’t help, either.

Renee Dechert

Jul 1, 2022


Two weeks ago, I wrote about the Rockies’ tendency to hit ground balls, an especially self-destructive tendency when a team plays half its games at Coors Field. Currently, the Rockies have the third-highest GB% in baseball (46.1%). They narrowly trail the Cubs (46.5%) and the Nationals (46.4%) for this honor. 

Since then, I’ve been thinking about double plays — specifically, how do the Rockies compare with other teams in terms of hitting into double plays, and which players on the team are most apt to hit into a double play? What I found surprised me.

Do the Rockies Have a GDP Problem?

Yes.

Just as a refresher, a GIDP (ground into double play) “occurs when a player hits a ground ball that results in multiple outs on the bases.” They most often take place on hard-hit ground balls, and it follows that the odds of a GIDP increase when the ball is hit by a player who is a slow runner.

Let’s start with 2021 to provide a contrast. Last year, the Rockies hit into 98 double plays, resulting in their having the 25th fewest GIDPs in baseball. (The Rays had the fewest with 75.) The league average was 111, so the Rockies were a very good team by this measure. 

However, in 2022, the Rockies have already hit into 67 GIDPs, roughly two-thirds of their 2021 total. Currently, the Rockies are second only to the Nationals with 72. (Interesting note here: The Diamondbacks have hit into only 38, the third fewest in baseball while the Dodgers have hit into only 43.) 

This shouldn’t be a surprise. Logically, it follows that when a team is hitting a lot of ground balls, they also increase their chances of hitting into double plays — and if anything kills offensive momentum, it’s a double-play. Right now, the Rockies need all the offensive help they can get, but the high number of GIDPs illustrates another way in which they are failing, especially in comparison to their NL West counterparts. 

Which Rockies Are the Biggest Offenders?

This is where things get interesting. 

(Before going further, let’s keep Elehuris Montero out of this discussion — he just hasn’t had enough opportunities — but I also wanted to leave his data in this table to provide an early benchmark.)

This table shows individual opportunities to hit into double plays followed by the number of instances in which that happened. Those numbers are then converted to a percentage. 

Source: Baseball Reference

Charlie Blackmon has had the most opportunities to hit into a GIDP (78), but has done so only 4 times for a GIDP% of 5.1%. (The league average is 10.0%.) CJ Cron is close behind Blackmon with 76 opportunities, but a considerably higher GIDP% of 13.2%. So Charlie Blackmon is exceptionally good at not hitting into double plays. (Hold that thought. I’ll come back to it in the next section.)

Contrast that with Yonathan Daza and José Iglesias, who are both having good years in terms of making contact and hitting singles. However, Daza has a GIDP% of 14.3% while Iglesias’ is 17.0%. Both are much higher than Blackmon’s. With this in mind, Bud Black’s consistent use of the Blackmon in the second spot in the batting order makes sense as does placing Iglesias further down the lineup.

Almost as good as Blackmon is Kris Bryant, though we’ve seen little of him due to injuries. Still, at this point, Bryant is well below the league average of 10.0%.

Consider the other two players who are below league average: Sam Hilliard and Ryan McMahon. Hilliard is currently in Albuquerque because he’s having trouble making contact. That said, when he has the opportunity to hit into a double play (which has happened 33 times in 2022), he has done so only twice. One other weird thing: Ryan McMahon has had 46 opportunities to hit into a double play this season but has hit into only one. Connor Joe may be the Greatest Rockie Ever, but Ryan McMahon is much better at avoiding rally-killing double plays — and they’ve had equal opportunities.

It’s also worth noting that Garrett Hampson is just barely above league average at 10.5%, which strikes me as close enough. 

That means that eight Rockies are above league average in terms of hitting into double plays. Who are most apt to hit into a GIDP? The first is Elias Díaz (27 opportunities, for 5 GIDP or 18.5%), who is struggling offensively.

Brendan Rodgers, who is slightly behind Díaz in GIDP% (18.2%) has had 66 opportunities and grounded into 12 double plays, like this one:

GIDP

mlb.comBrendan Rodgers grounds into a double play, third baseman Max Muncy to second baseman Gavin Lux to first baseman Freddie Freeman. Kris Brya…Brendan Rodgers grounds into a double play, third baseman Max Muncy to second baseman Gavin Lux to first baseman Freddie Freeman. Kris Bryant out at 2nd. Brendan Rodgers out at 1st.9:33 PM ∙ Jun 30, 2022

The Rockies need more offense, and one way to do that is to reduce the number of double plays they hit into.

How Do the Rockies Compare in Terms of Speed?

Remember: The second factor that influences a double play is speed, and when it comes to being fleet of foot, the Rockies are a bit whatever. According to Baseball Savant, the average sprint speed in MLB is 27 feet/second. So, half of the Rockies’ roster is above average in terms of speed, and half is below average. 

Source: Baseball Savant

It makes sense, then, Hampson, Hilliard, Blackmon, and Bryant, four of the fastest Rockies, also have a lower GIDP%. Of course, Iglesias and Daza are also fast players, but they still have a high GIDP%, so speed isn’t everything. 

But it’s also a big difference between Charlie Blackmon and CJ Cron: Blackmon is just faster, so he beats out double plays more often than Cron does. 

Did You Stumble Onto Anything Interesting While Writing This?

You know, I did — two things, actually. The first oddity builds on the piece I wrote last week about Charlie Blackmon as an effective designated hitter. 

This graphic from Baseball Savant illustrates by position how Rockies players compare to other teams in terms of speed. The Rockies are the colored dots on the chart, and I’ve tagged Charlie Blackmon.

There’s nothing too revelatory here: The slow players (e.g., Rodgers, Cron, Díaz, McMahon) are slower than average when compared to other players in their positions. But look at Charlie Blackmon, who is one of the fastest designated hitters in baseball. Only Andrew McCutchen, Harold Ramirez, and Shohei Ohtani are faster than Blackmon. 

Charlie Blackmon may not like being a designated hitter, but he’s good at it — and his speed makes him more effective and reduces the odds that he will hit into a double play.

Here’s the other interesting note. In 2021, Trevor Story had the opportunity to hit into 116 double plays, but he only did seven times for a GIDP% of 6.0%, the lowest on the team for anyone with a minimum of 250 plate appearances. (The league average was 9.6%.) That’s amazingly good. In 2022, however, Story has a GIDP% of 10.8%, so he’s not doing as well this year as last year (and that may be due to his slow start). That said, he’s just slightly above average, and I expect that to come down as the season plays out. Also, Story is better than his replacement, José Iglesias, at not grounding into double plays. In 2021, Iglesias had a GIDP% of 17.0%, so this is just part of his game. 

But it indicates another way in which the Rockies miss Trevor Story.

Final Thoughts

I don’t have any quick answer for this except to note — again — that a moribund Rockies offense needs to elevate the baseball. 


Down on the Farm

Twitter avatar for @RockiesClubInfoRockies Club Information @RockiesClubInfo

It was announced today by @MiLB that outfielder Jesus Bugarin has been named the Arizona Complex League's Player of the Week for the week of June 20-26. During that span, the 20-year-old went 7-for-16 (.438) with 2 2B, 1 3B, 1 HR & 6 RBI, putting up a 1.349 OPS and a .500 BAbip.

Image

5:17 PM ∙ Jun 27, 2022


  • Aaron Schunk’s dad has talent!

Twitter avatar for @ericschunkeric schunk @ericschunk

My sketch of the @GoYardGoats Dunkin Donuts Park (plus handiwork on the ball I got to throw out to Aaron on Father’s Day). Did the drawing over a two-game period, totaling about 2 hours. @RealSlimSchunky @Rockies @MiLB

Image

12:40 PM ∙ Jun 28, 2022


Old Friends 


What I’m Reading, Watching, & Listening To


Weekend Walk-off

For Avalanche fans, this was an epic week. For Rockies fans, it was great to see the Avs and the Stanley Cup at Coors Field and moments like this one involving Avs superfan Kyle Freeland. 

Twitter avatar for @ATTSportsNetRMAT&T SportsNet™ | RM @ATTSportsNetRM

Nailed it @GabeLandeskog92 and @KFREE_21 ! #GoAvsGo #Rockies

1:03 AM ∙ Jun 30, 2022


This week also provided Rockies fans with a bitter reminder of how the team’s ownership has failed them. The Commissioner’s Trophy isn’t coming to Denver anytime soon. 

Thanks for reading —

Renee


The Rockies weren’t very good, but a lot happened.

Renee Dechert

Oct 4, 2021


Yesterday, the Rockies’ 2021 season came to a close. During one of the most exciting final days of the regular season in recent memory, the Rockies were playing meaningless baseball in a half-empty Chase Field. 

Twitter avatar for @choice_fielderMax Bay @choice_fielder

Anybody else as pumped as I am for the Rockies Diamondbacks game?

6:48 PM ∙ Oct 3, 2021

(To be clear, Bay is an avid Dodgers fan, so his tone is sarcastic.) 

The Rockies finished with a record of 74-87, (48-33 at Coors Field; 26-54 on the road). They were better than a lot of pundits thought they would be, but the last three years have shown the Rockies to be a 70-win team, not a serious playoff contender, despite ownership assessments like this: “I truly in my heart believe that this is a very talented team that underperformed the last couple of years.” The “guys playing better” strategy has been remarkably consistent— and not in a good way.

The offseason in baseball is about autopsying what has happened with an eye to next year. I enjoy those kinds of exercises, and I’ll be started by the end of the week. First, though, I wanted to take a moment and consider what happened this year, especially in light of the Rockies’ (unsurprising) decision to name Bill Schmidt permanent general manager. Despite their record, it was a big year for the Rockies.

Here’s some of the news from 2021.

  • Jeff Bridich Resigned, and Bill Schmidt Became General Manager — No one was surprised by the decision, especially given that it came in a highly insular organization. Generally speaking, it was not well received:

Twitter avatar for @EricGoodmanEric Goodman @EricGoodman

Former MLB Executive on #Rockies hiring Bill Schmidt as GM.. “Confirms their total lack of self awareness along w/extending their prevailing ineptitude by design. They didn't even seek outside opinions & methodology. It's baffling to the baseball world, absolutely inexplicable!”

6:41 PM ∙ Oct 3, 2021

I’m ambivalent about Schmidt being named general manager. As someone who’s spent time working in situations without clear leadership, I’m sympathetic to a group saying, “We can’t handle more change. Just give us stability for awhile.” Apparently, for the Rockies, Schmidt has done that. 

In addition, we know that the Rockies were hemorrhaging staff. Schmidt has begun filling positions left vacant, including hiring Scott Van Lenten to oversee research and development. None of this is sexy or revelatory, but stability matters. 

(If you’re interested, there’s a link to Bill Schmidt’s interview with Jack Corrigan here.)

Moreover, I remain convinced that the Rockies are an organization operating under “The Plan” Jeff Bridich devised. That may explain Schmidt’s open-ended contract. Since The Plan ends when the starting rotation is no longer operable, the occupant of Jeff Bridich’s office is less important. (To be clear, the initial results have been mixed.)

I would also assume that Bridich’s leaving was less a firing than an expression of dissatisfaction at Dick Monfort’s decision to promote Greg Feasel. The timing suggests the two were not a coincidence. Moreover, I suspect the #FireBridich campaign got to him. He hadn’t seemed happy for a long time. 

But anyone who thinks the Bridich Years are over is being premature. It takes time to assess leadership effectiveness and evaluate the fallout from decisions made by a previous administration. In the fall of 2009, I remember a student telling the library director (who also has a PhD in history) that he wanted to write his research paper on whether Barack Obama was a good president. Susan explained to him that decades pass before it’s possible to evaluate a president — they’d only just received Bill Clinton’s papers the previous month. That’s going to be the case with Jeff Bridich. We know he was a terrible communicator, and we know he was bad at signing free agents, but we won’t understand his legacy for awhile.

  • Nolan Arenado Was Traded — We knew Arenado was unhappy, and in February, he punched his ticket out of Colorado. For fans, it was distressing for a number of reasons: A lack of closure; the loss of the face of the franchise and a generational talent; questions about the return the Rockies received; and a revelation in the national media of the Rockies’ front office incompetence. Arenado sent the fans a goodbye video, but it was hard. Without Arenado, who were the Colorado Rockies? It also showed how little the Rockies understand their fans.

Speaking for myself, I found Arenado’s return to Coors Field for the All-Star Game deeply satisfying — and I feel like when he took the field and I got to give him a standing ovation, I was through it. (Fandom is a weird relationship.) Emotion aside, Arenado’s exit from Colorado fundamentally changed the franchise.

  • The All-Star Game Came to Coors Field — It was unexpected (and surely a cash cow for the Rockies and McGregor Square). It was also a very big deal — albeit hastily thrown together. (Someone, please, explain those uniforms. They still don’t make sense outside of Atlanta.) Seeing Arenado and Germán Márquez support Trevor Story in the Home Run Derby was very cool, and that moment when Márquez pitched with Arenado picking up a ground ball and firing it to first was pretty special, too. I feel like we earned that, and we only got that moment because of a series of actions that were unplanned when the season began.

For a week, the baseball world revolved around Denver.

  • Larry Walker Entered the Hall of Fame — The Rockies finally have a presence in Cooperstown, which is pretty terrific. In addition, the Rockies celebrated Walker’s career and retired his number (which was probably a good way to fill Coors Field at the end of the season when the team was out of the playoff chase). 

“I want you to view that plaque with a certain amount of pride,” Walker said during his Coors Field speech. “I want you to see it with your face on it, not mine. . . . Today I don’t say I have a plaque in Cooperstown, I say WE have a plaque in Cooperstown.” Everything about Larry Walker’s HOF induction was a big deal. 

  • Trevor Story Is (Probably) Done as a Rockie — All that was missing from Nolan Arenado’s Colorado exit happened for Trevor Story. The last week of the Rockies’ season felt like an ongoing eulogy. He addressed fans; he gave away his Rockies gear; he was emotional about leaving his teammates. In the way that the hiring of Bill Schmidt provided a strange parallel to Jeff Bridich’s early-season exit, Trevor Story’s final games with Colorado framed a season that began with the Arenado deal.

The Rockies’ handling of Arenado and Story also raised similar questions about the front office’s ability to manage a professional baseball team. 

Fans did turn out to Coors Field this season, even as their team faded from contention. After the Rockies opened for full capacity on June 28 against the Pirates in a kind of second swing at Opening Day, they averaged 30,263 fans the rest of the season. A persistent pandemic kept crowds down across baseball, it seemed, but for the Rockies, their attendance dipped.

Over the same time period in 2019, the last time Coors Field was open for full capacity, the Rockies averaged 38,525 fans, even as they again faded from contention. Their 2021 attendance amounted to a 24 percent full-capacity decrease. Two years ago, the Rockies ranked sixth in attendance in the majors. Even after their slide, and even though an accurate, league-wide accounting is difficult this year, the Rockies probably finished among the top 10 in attendance. Coors Field remains a draw.

Turns out, there’s a cost to fielding a marginal baseball team.

  • A Thought About Dick Monfort and Fans — I’ve come to wonder if Dick Monfort has become fan shy. This was brought home to me while watching the Larry Walker festivities when an unannounced Dick Monfort made his way to the podium to give a speech. He did this, presumably, not because of an error in the program but rather to decrease the chances of fans booing him. (I’ve heard from some who were at the game they were prepared to do so.)

If that’s the case, and if Monfort is, indeed, susceptible to fan criticism, then perhaps fans have found a pressure point that would work better than attendance boycotts.

Just a thought.

With that, now that we have all the data, it’s time to autopsy 2021 and begin planning for the future. These were just a few points outside the numbers that felt worth revisiting. 

So, when do the Winter Leagues start?


Thank You for Reading

September 26 marked the first anniversary of Rockies Pitch, and I wanted to thank you for subscribing to this newsletter, reading it, recommending it, and making suggestions for improvement. Everyone has too much stuff to read, so I appreciate this newsletter being added to your inbox. 

When I started Rockies Pitch, I told myself if I had 30 readers who appreciated the content, that would be enough. I passed that goal early on, and the numbers have surpassed my expectations. Excessive thanks can become maudlin, so I’ll stop now, but always know that I am grateful. 

Look for the regular Rockies Pitch on Friday.

Renee

@307Renee


What does this suggest about the team’s 2022 plans?

Renee Dechert

Oct 1, 2021


The 2021 MLB season is winding down, but some of the Rockies will play on during the offseason.

Twitter avatar for @d_allentuckDanielle Allentuck @d_allentuck

The plan right now is for Rolison to play the first half of the season. Sam Hilliard, Brian Serven, Dom Nuñez and Chris Owings are among the other #Rockies players planning to play winer ball this year.

9:11 PM ∙ Sep 27, 2021

The Rolison announcement is official:

Twitter avatar for @TigresdelLiceyTigres del Licey @TigresdelLicey

Anunciamos la contratación del lanzador zurdo Ryan Rolison, prospecto #3 de los Rockies de Colorado y Samad Taylor, prospecto #17 de Blue Jay nombrado como el Mejor Corredor de Bases Liga Noreste AA, por Baseball America 2021. ¡Bienvenido a la #FamiliaAzul 🐅💙! #ElGlorioso

2:54 PM ∙ Sep 27, 2021

Given that Rolison missed significant time due to appendicitis and a finger injury, it makes sense that the Rockies want him to build up his innings in preparation for 2022. In addition, Thomas Harding writes that the Dominican Winter League is “a highly competitive atmosphere that can often serve as a bridge to the intensity of the Majors.”

Ryan Rolison isn’t the only Rockie who will be playing winter ball. Sam Hilliard, Julian Fernández, Brian Serven, Dom Nuñez, Chris Owings, and Colton Welker will play as well, and there are rumors that Jordan Sheffield will, too. (Final rosters as well as Arizona Fall League rosters should be available in the next few days.)

Hilliard will be playing in the Mexican Pacific League as he continues to hone his approach at the plate. Hilliard has shortened his swing in an attempt to increase contact and reduce strikeouts, so it makes sense that he would further that work in the offseason.

He has acknowledged the changes have required some practice. “I’m a long guy and I have long levers, so I’m just shortening my swing as much as I can. I believe I’m on my way to getting the most out of the swing that I have. That’s just about cleaning up some things,” Hilliard said.

While Bud Black has been positive about the changes Hilliard has made, he acknowledges there’s more to be done. “He has to continue to work on putting the ball in play,” Black told Patrick Saunders, “And we have seen a more concentrated effort to do that, even with two strikes. Sam, with his strength, if he just puts the ball in play more, I think the average will climb.” In other words, the Rockies have some clear expectations, and Hilliard is attempting to meet them (and, presumably, earn a starting outfield spot).

Joining Hilliard in the Mexican Pacific League is Colton Welker. Given that Welker served an 80-game PED suspension, causing him to miss most of the season, he will benefit from additional playing time as he attempts to earn a starting spot in 2022.

The other teams that will host the Rockies remain unknown. 

In the past, the Rockies have used winter baseball to help players recover after missing a season due to injuries (e.g., Chi Chi Gonzálex and Charlie Blackmon, whose stay in the Dominican Republic is archived in his Twitter feed for anyone curious enough to do some excavating). Presumably, Owings and Sheffield will be playing to make up for missed time due to injuries. But this offseason will have an usually high number of Rockies seeing additional action — they have typically only sent four or five players. This year, the Rockies have eight players who will participate in the Winter Leagues, which marks a decided shift.

What does it mean? Here are a few theories.

  • There’s a New Boss — Since the Rockies have a new (albeit interim) general manager in Bill Schmidt, it makes sense that there would be changes in the organization’s player development strategies. We won’t know if this strategy worked until Spring Training, but it suggests a new philosophy in the Rockies’ offseason player development.

It also hints that a frugal Rockies organization will attempt to develop what they have as opposed to spending heavily on free agents or making trades. The Rockies have been known to overvalue their prospects, and this move to additional offseason player development suggests that part of the organizational philosophy remains unchanged. * The Rockies Want to Give Hilliard and Nuñez a Chance to Improve — Neither player had an especially remarkable season in 2021. Hilliard has slashed .211/.288/.441 for a wRC+ of 77 and an fWAR of 0.2; Nuñez went .182/.287/.368 for a wRC+ of 66 and an fWAR of 0.3. Nuñez has been a disappointing catcher on both sides of the plate — a fact even more noticeable given the year Elias Díaz has had (92 wRC+; 1.5 fWAR). Like Hilliard, Nuñez is preparing to make a case for himself in spring training. Before that, he will play for the Indios de Mayagüez in the Puerto Rican Winter League.

The fact that Brian Serven is also playing winter baseball suggests there may be competition for Nuñez if his game doesn’t pick up. This year in Albuquerque, Serven slashed .247/.303/.498 for a wRC+ of 89. To be fair, it’s Minor League baseball, but Serven clearly wants his chance.

If the Rockies want to build on their current starting rotation, other parts of the team must perform better, notably an offensively anemic outfield. I expect the Rockies’ outfield to look different in 2022; by playing the Winter Leagues, Hilliard is trying to earn a spot.  * The Rockies Are Trying to Get the Pitching Staff Up to Speed — The Rockies have given Peter Lamber and Ryan Feltner MLB time during September to see where they are — an ERA of 11.37 in 6.1 IP and 11.12 ERA in 5.2 IP, respectively. Rolison will be afforded that opportunity in the Dominican Republic. This suggests that the Rockies are planning for a rotation without Jon Gray in the event they are unable to re-sign him or looking for that sixth starter in the event of a starter injury. 

Sheffield and Fernández are destined to help a marginal bullpen that had the fourth-highest ERA in baseball (4.90 and an fWAR of only 1.5). These relievers need more work, especially a 25-year-old Julian Fernández.

Final Thoughts

Russell A. Carleton’s research indicates that playing in the Winter Leagues has little impact on most players, so it may not matter. But it does show a Rockies team trying something a little different as they make plans for 2022. 

It also gives Rockies fans something to look forward to in the offseason because watching Winter League Baseball — even if you don’t speak Spanish — is a lot of fun.


Down on the Farm

  • The Rockies have released their roster for their Instructional League. (Read it here.) Zac Veen and Benny Montgomery will be playing on the same team, which is exciting.

Old Friends

  • I got this prediction wrong — though my prediction was always predicated on the Cards having a losing season:

Twitter avatar for @stlsportscntrlSTL Sports Central @stlsportscntrl

BREAKING: Nolan Arenado confirms that he will not be opting out of his contract this offseason, will notify the #STLCards formally of his decision, Derrick Goold reports

Image

10:54 PM ∙ Sep 29, 2021


  • The Tyler Anderson-Tom Murphy battery continues to roll with the Mariners tied for the second AL Wildcard:

Twitter avatar for @MarinersSeattle Mariners @Mariners

Shoutout to TA 👏

Image

3:46 AM ∙ Sep 29, 2021


For Some Fans, Even Less Access

  • Yesterday, Dish stopped carrying the AT&T SportsNet and Root Sports. According to Awful Announcing:

Everything about the move is frustrating, especially for Mariners fans, who just want to watch their team as it attempts to make the postseason for the first time in 20 years. (It’s also a loss for rural viewers with limited options — like my parents, who haven’t seen a Nuggets game in two years unless it was on a national broadcast). 

This underscores the extent to which MLB blackouts are barriers to fans who want to watch teams play and are willing to do so. If the networks cannot get along with service providers, fans should be able to go around them, and MLB should facilitate the process, not stay wedded to an outdated delivery model.


What I’m Reading, Watching, and Listening To


Weekend Walk-off

The series against the Nationals may have marked Trevor Story’s last time to play at Coors Field as a Rockie. Here’s how the Rockies took the field on Wednesday:

Twitter avatar for @RoxGifsVidsRoxGifsVids @RoxGifsVids

7:40 PM ∙ Sep 29, 2021

Story has made clear that he hopes to be playing elsewhere in 2022, and he may well be though it’s going to be a tough year to be a free-agent shortstop.

But while watching this, along with Story giving his Rockies gear to fans after the game, I couldn’t stop thinking about the framing of this season: It began with the Nolan Arenado trade and ended with Trevor Story (probably) leaving as a free agent in a year when the Rockies had another losing season.

Earlier in the day, the Rockies emailed season ticket holders, telling them to save the date for October 11 when they could begin buying their 2022 tickets, which, given everything going on, showed an inability to read the room.

For fans, all of this is disappointing and reinforces the extent to which the front office does not understand Rockies fans (and doesn’t seem much interested in working it out).

Thanks for reading —

Renee

@307Renee


For all the talk of draft and develop, 2021 data suggests some problems with the Rockies’ system.

Renee Dechert

Sep 3, 2021


Back in June, I wrote about the Rockies’ offense — it was not good then and has not improved much since. Here’s how all MLB teams rank in terms of wRC+ where 100 is league average.1

Source: FanGraphs

That’s right: The baseball team that plays half of its games at Coors Field is tied with the Pirates for the lowest wRC+ in baseball. That borders on unbelievable. The Rockies have hit 150 home runs — 10 of them grand slams, the most in Rockies history — which is 22nd in baseball. (For what it’s worth, the Rockies are better than the Cardinals with 147). By comparison, the Giants, who play half of their games at Oracle Park, lead the league in home runs with 201 (although Mike Petriello points out that recent changes to Oracle may be affecting the numbers). 

Also note that the top ten teams are all playoff contenders. Offense matters. Moreover, these teams have invested in data and/or personnel while the Rockies have had other priorities.

Now consider the wRC+ rankings of individual Rockies:

Source: FanGraphs

Three players are above average as measured by wRC+: C.J. Cron, Connor Joe, and Brendan Rodgers. The two best players, Cron and Joe, are not products of the Rockies’ development system; rather, both were signed as free agents in the offseason. For all the talk of the Rockies as a “draft-and-develop team,” they have not built a particularly good offense, at least as measured by wRC+, since 2017. 

That said, watching Brendan Rodgers come into his own has been a treat. He’s come to have a reliable presence at the plate. Trevor Story, Ryan McMahon, and Charlie Blackmon have all had disappointing years offensively though they are close to being league average, and McMahon has spent much of the season above it. 

One other point is worth noting: The Rockies outfield has little offensive value. Raimel Tapia, Yonathan Daza, Sam Hilliard, and Garrett Hampson have all had miserable years offensively. None of them is above 80 in terms of wRC+. If Hampson continues to shine as a center fielder, the Rockies may be able to compensate for his lack of offense, but they cannot continue to carry unproductive outfielders. 

All of this suggests possible systemic evaluation and developmental issues with the Rockies’ road record (18-50) indicating an even-more-pressing need to address the Coors Field effect.

As it turns out, this week, the Rockies began advertising for three “Baseball Operations Research and Development” positions. (Read the job listings here.) I don’t know enough about these jobs to evaluate what the Rockies are asking for, but I do know that $85,000-$95,000 for this kind of position is not a competitive salary. 

In related news, Thomas Harding reported that Bill Schmidt has begun filling positions in the Rockies’ front office. Schmidt insists the general manager position has not yet been determined, but all indications are that he has the job. (In this piece, Sheryl Ring explains how easy it is for front offices to get around the “Selig Rule,” so should Schmidt get the position, it would be no surprise.)

As Schmidt has made his media rounds, he has spoken — as Rockies general managers before him have — of the team’s reliance on drafting and developing players. wRC+ indicates that strategy as implemented by the Rockies has not been terribly successful for some time. If the Rockies plan to contend, they will need better data and new ideas. While it appears they’re trying to rebuild their depleted analytics department, low salaries suggest that the Rockies still aren’t terribly invested in the science. (Organizations spend money on things they value.) 

Similarly, front office promotions from within do nothing to contradict the appearance that these changes are little more than performative. The Rockies cannot bring themselves, either because of financial choices or team culture, to embrace anything new. The odds are they cannot win until they do.

Share Rockies Pitch: A Newsletter about Baseball & Fandom


Down on the Farm

Twitter avatar for @FresnoGrizzliesFresno Grizzlies @FresnoGrizzlies

Celebrate #TacoTuesday by bidding on a game-worn, signed, Fresno Tacos jersey! 🌮⚾️ Enter the auction here: bit.ly/21TacoJerseyAu…

Image

Image

Image

9:46 PM ∙ Aug 31, 2021 * The crisis in MiLB housing is receiving more attention, this time from J.J. Cooper. It’s past time for MLB to deal with this issue.  * Nick Groke has some insights on the Rockies’ MiLB system. (Groke also has some reporting here on David Dahl, who, clearly, is no longer a prospect, but I found this really interesting.) * Don’t lose track of the Rockie’s Arizona Complex League team. Kyle Newman reports that the Rockies think Adael Amador and Benny Montgomery will be playing at Coors Field in four or five years. The future looks promising.


Accolades (and Some Gossip)

C.J. Cron has been named the August NL Player of the Month:

Source: MLB Press Release

Cron is the 11th Rockie to earn this award. (The most recent was Charlie Blackmon in June 2019.)

Last week, Bob Nightengale reported this:

Twitter avatar for @BNightengaleBob Nightengale @BNightengale

C.J. Cron, who turned down an offer from the #Dodgers during the winter and bet on himself to be an everyday player with the #Rockies, hits a 3-run HR in the 1st inning vs. LA. Cron now has 24 homers and 76 RBI with a .914 OPS

8:31 PM ∙ Aug 29, 2021

So Cron decided against being a Dodger, which is interesting — and suggests that perhaps the odds of the Rockies re-signing him are good. While Cron did sign a 2021 one-year contract for $1 million with the Rockies, it also includes incentives: He can earn additional performance bonuses: “$200,000 each for 50, 75, 100 and 125, and $300,000 apiece for 140 and 145. He would get a $500,000 one-time assignment bonus if traded.” Cron has been, hands down, one of the Rockies’ most valuable players and a terrific investment.


Old Friends

  • I’m still a Tyler Anderson fan, so a possible return to Seattle in 2022 sounds like a good fit to me, especially since fellow old friend Tom Murphy is catching there.

Twitter avatar for @CoreyBrockMLBCorey Brock @CoreyBrockMLB

Tyler Anderson loads the bases with no outs. Tyler Anderson retires the next three hitters. Tyler Anderson returns to Seattle in 2022.

9:06 PM ∙ Aug 28, 2021


  • Gerardo Parra is now selling a limited Parra Shark speaker. As the ad explains, “Be happy as long as you live!” You can read more here. (I was a little disappointed “Baby Shark” didn’t start auto-playing when I opened the website.)

What I’m Reading, Watching, and Listening To

  • Neil Paine’s “The Best, Worst And Weirdest Stats Of The 2021 MLB Season”(538.com) — You knew the #RoadRockies would make this one, but so do Ryan McMahon and Raimel Tapia. (Here’s an early prediction: The Rockies will attempt to trade and then non-tender Tapia.)
  • Patrick Saunders’ “Will the Rockies Be Spenders This Offseason? Colorado Faces Major Payroll Questions with Contracts Coming off the Books” (Denver Post) — Saunders does the math. (Here’s another prediction: The Rockies will go to shorter but more lucrative contracts, like the Daniel Murphy deal. No more Ian Desmond or Nolan Arenado long-term commitments.) 
  • Joelle Milholm’s “September Could Be a Good Indicator of the Rockies’ Future”(Purple Row) — For Milholm, September will be more meaningful than the Rockies’ record in the next 30 games.
  • Justin Wick’s “Austin Gomber Has Shown a Wild Pitch Mix in His Last Three Starts” (Purple Row) — I remain bullish on Gomber as a Rockie. I’ve come to suspect that part of Gomber’s issues arise from the fatigue of this being his first season as a rotation starter.
  • Drew Goodman’s “Rockies Starter Austin Gomber” (The Drew Goodman Podcast) — I always appreciate Goodman’s podcast because I think players are comfortable with him, and they have very honest conversation. Last week, Goodman spoke with Gomber, and the week before, Kyle Freeland. Both pitchers are clear about one thing: They believe the Rockies are close. Much of the baseball world may not believe in the Rockies, but I think they believe in themselves — and I think the front office will spend some money in the offseason to show they do, too.
  • Robert Murray’s “St. Louis Discussed Perameters of Trevor Story Trade” (Redbird Rants) — Cardinal fans’ fixation on reconstructing the Rockies’ former left side is fascinating. Were Arenado and Story an electric combination? Absolutely. Are their best days behind them? Very probably. Here’s what Murray writes: “Story could be a candidate for a lucrative one-year deal similar to what Semien signed with the Blue Jays. A one-year, $18 or so million deal could stretch the books for the Cardinals in 2022, but that and other upgrades throughout the roster would give them a real chance at competing for a title in Yadier Molina’s last season.” Maybe. Consider me skeptical.

Weekend Walk-off

There has not been a lot of joy this season for the #RoadRockies, and that’s been true for Trevor Story, too, who’s had a down year.

However, his bat flip game is a thing of beauty. See for yourself:

Twitter avatar for @RockiesColorado Rockies @Rockies

@PurpleRow we got you :)

Image

2:13 AM ∙ Aug 31, 2021

His bat flips have become their own art form.

Thanks for reading —

Renee

@307Renee

1 This data is current as of September 2, 2021.

For the organization, it’s become a year of opportunity, but will they take it?

Renee Dechert

May 6, 2021


On Monday, the Rockies announced that Vice President of Scouting Bill Schmidt would assume the role of Interim General Manager. Schmidt has been in the Rockies organization for more than 20 years, serving as Scouting Director since 2007 and overseeing the Rockies MLB Draft since 2000. 

The good news is that the Rockies (we hope) have begun sorting through the issues confronting them. Filling the interim position shows the organization being proactive; Schmidt’s relationships should help the Rockies improve their work with other teams; his history with players throughout the system should facilitate better communication. All of this is good. (There’s still the problem of the out-sourced analytics department, but the organization has to start somewhere.)

On Wednesday morning, Schmidt met with the media. I wasn’t able to watch that (read Thomas Harding’s reporting here), but I did see his in-game conversation with Ryan Spilborghs (available here).

It was a nice format in which to introduce Schmidt to fans. Spilborghs knows Schmidt well, and the two had a friendly conversation. Schmidt stressed his history and relationships with players (both inside and outside the Rockies organization), and he reiterated that he was in the position to ensure “everyone is pulling the rope in the same direction.” He named others in the organization who would be key in moving forward — and said that he wasn’t smart enough to do everything himself. (I’d call that some “brain surgeon shade.”)

In a purely interpersonal sense, Schmidt seemed knowledgeable, approachable, and likable. He talked about players he’d scouted — for example, Schmidt first saw Ryan McMahon when going to a baseball camp with his son. In telling these kinds of stories, he created an immediate connection with fans. He made jokes and stressed that he was there to improve communication. His language was clear and concise. There was no sense he was hiding anything or that he’d rather be anywhere else. He was just stopping by the booth to visit with an old friend — and to introduce himself to fans.

It’s a good start. 

Now, it’s time for the Rockies to begin the next phase of rebuilding trust with fans. Here’s how Thomas Harding put it last week:

_The hard feelings of the Arenado trade have been dissected to death. The lesson should be that transparency must improve. Fans have been displeased with the product on the field the last two years, but an underlying cause for the anger is that decisions were made to keep them in the dark about the team’s plans.  

If the Rockies have to shop their best players now to enhance the future, they'd benefit from telling everyone — even if reaction is negative. Monfort and new club president Greg Feasel can help with this attitude by keeping stand-up baseball people around when the new hires are made._

Harding is right (although I’d argue there’s more Arenado “dissection” to be done), and I’d like to offer some suggestions to the Rockies as they begin the work of constructively engaging fans.

Hold Another Press Conference — A Real One

When the news of the Schmidt hiring dropped, Patrick Saunders tweeted this:

Twitter avatar for @psaundersdpPatrick Saunders @psaundersdp

Here's hoping the interim GM will actually talk to the media. ... Without being condescending.

Twitter avatar for @DPRockiesDenver Post Rockies @DPRockies

NEW: Bill Schmidt named #Rockies interim general manager, replacing Jeff Bridich via @psaundersdp https://t.co/xYiXbKtwdo

6:45 PM ∙ May 3, 2021


Rockies, he’s offering you some advice. 

Now that Schmidt has made his first appearance as Interim GM, it’s time for the next step. Holding a press conference with Dick Monfort, Greg Feasel, and Schmidt would serve several purposes. First, it would allow everyone to see the new leadership in place — the new team, if you will. Visuals matter. Second, it would indicate that the Rockies are beginning to re-engage with the larger world of MLB. National writers were perplexed by the Rockies’ failure to hold a press conference in the wake of the Bridich resignation. A press conference shows an attempt to be, well, a normal baseball team — and normal baseball teams engage with the baseball community.

Third, it would allow the Rockies to begin their repair work on their relationship with local media. Those beat writers mediate the relationship between the organization and fans. Right now, the Rockies are re-setting, but they also need to open themselves up to a conversation with the writers who know them best.

If Coors Field can allow fans again and if the team is 100% vaccinated, then the Rockies can arrange for a safe in-person media availability. Zoom gives the Rockies too much control over the situation — and I say this as someone who adores Zoom. If it’s a new day, then it deserves a forum suited to an honest conversation and trust building.

Monfort, Feasel, and Schmidt Need to Do Some Interviews

The press conference sets the tone for what’s next. The real conversations should happen between those in power and reporters they’re comfortable having more nuanced visits with. 

Like Patrick Saunders, Harding has offered the Rockies some advice:

Twitter avatar for @harding_at_mlbThomas Harding @hardingatmlb

@rocktober19 @psaundersdp Full disclosure: I hate press conferences. They can make idiots of us all. Talking to a player/manager/front office person/exec face-to-face leads to better stories. There is time to hammer out nuance. Even worse, press conferences are performance art, made for grandstanding ...

3:14 PM ∙ May 4, 2021


Those face-to-face conversations should be with media figures Rockies fans know and trust, reporters who understand the team and the fanbase. (Spilborghs is a good start — fans like him — but he’s not exactly a seasoned journalist. The front office needs to talk with those willing to ask harder questions.)

The front office’s message — and I don’t know what that is, though hopefully they do — needs to be clear, and each member of the front office should address a specific component of that message (e.g., Monfort on vision; Feasel on finance; and Schmidt on the team). 

In having those conversations, the front office is effectively telling fans what’s happening and giving them a sense of the plan. If the Rockies want fan buy-in, fans have to feel like they’re stakeholders. For that to happen, the leadership needs to speak directly with fans (even if that message is heavily scripted). This is about building trust, and that involves some vulnerability on both sides. The Rockies front office has to carry their share of that burden.

Solicit Fan Feedback

Rockies social media has been a dumpster fire since the Arenado deal — and, to be clear, the Rockies social team did not deserve that, but it doesn’t matter. Fans use those platforms because they’re available and provide the closest thing most fans have in terms of a direct voice to the organization. It’s time to change the tenor of that conversation.

Since the Rockies have been hinting that 2021 was “The Year of Opportunity,” it’s time to extend that symbolism to the organization itself. It’s an opportunity for the Rockies to recalibrate their relationships. 

To change the tone on social media, I’d create a Google form and distribute it widely soliciting feedback on pretty much anything fans want to vent about. Have thoughts on a rebuild? Share them. Concerned about beer prices? Let’s hear your ideas. Want to change the Tooth Trot? What do you have in mind? They should plan for a lot of venting and a lot of unworkable ideas and maybe some gems, but the point is to signal that it’s a new day: The Rockies want to hear from fans. 

Actions like this change the tone even if they don’t result in actionable ideas.

Communicate Regularly with Stakeholders

I assume right now, the Rockies are building a plan for the post-Bridich era. If they are, they should tell fans, and they should provide updates. Create a “fan liaison.” Clearly, fans can’t know everything: It’s a business. No one disputes that.

But the Rockies need to be clear about what fans can expect to know as stakeholders, and they need to plan on ways to regularly and personally get that message out. Those press statements that drop on social media simply aren’t personal enough. 

Twitter avatar for @RockiesColorado Rockies @Rockies

The Colorado Rockies announced today that they have named the club’s Vice President of Scouting Bill Schmidt their interim General Manager.

Image

6:34 PM ∙ May 3, 2021


Initiatives work best when they’re affiliated with a person.

Final Thoughts

Some fans have expressed concerns about Schmidt’s statement that he’d like to be considered for the permanent job. To that, I’ll offer two observations. Interim leaders generally say they hope a position becomes permanent, even if that’s not really their plan. Otherwise, they risk operating in a lame-duck capacity and having less influence on daily operations. Moreover, it helps calm the inevitable speculation.

Second, I’ve known lots of folks who took interim positions and discovered that it really wasn’t a job they wanted.

I recognize the Rockies’ history of hiring familiar people, but if that were Dick Monfort’s plan, I tend to think that Schmidt would already have the job. It is essential that the Rockies run a real search — and if Schmidt wishes to be considered, he should apply — but right now, this is about letting things settle. Schmidt’s history with the organization and his statement that he hopes to remain in the position achieves that, regardless of what happens in the fall.

The Rockies have a window, and they’ve made some moves fans have requested. None of that matters, however, if the Rockies don’t go all in on re-setting their relationship with fans.


Milestones

  • Reader, it happened: After 83 plate appearances in 2021, Josh Fuentes walked:

Twitter avatar for @RoxGifsVidsRoxGifsVids @RoxGifsVids

Josh Fuentes Walked

Image

11:56 PM ∙ May 4, 2021


During the second game of the double header against the Giants, Fuentes walked again. In doing so, he equaled the number of walks he took in 2020 in 103 plate appearances. 


Old Friends

  • Tyler Anderson continues to make a name for himself in Pittsburgh: On Monday, he carried a no-hitter against the Padres into the seventh inning. Anderson is having a good season, and I wonder if the Pirates will attempt to move him before the trade deadline.
  • C. Trent Rosencrans talked with Jeff Hoffman about how he selects the jerseys the Reds will wear. (Hoffman is a player I’m hoping good things for.)

Share


What I’m Reading, Watching, and Listening To


Weekend Walk-off

Since being a Ryan McMahon Defense Skeptic is apparently a thing now, I’ve decided it’s my lot in life to remind folks that McMahon is a very good defender. Check out this play during the second game against the Giants:

Twitter avatar for @RoxGifsVidsRoxGifsVids @RoxGifsVids

This double play 🔥

Image

2:06 AM ∙ May 5, 2021


I’ll say it: Ryan McMahon should be an All Star. 

Now to the emotional weekend waiting for everyone in St. Louis.

Thanks for reading —

Renee